“Black Phone 2“ Review: A Familiar Nightmare, faithfully Executed
“Black Phone 2″ arrives with meaningful anticipation, building on the chilling success of its predecessor. This sequel doesn’t reinvent the horror wheel, but it delivers a solid, often genuinely frightening experience. However,it grapples with familiar sequel pitfalls – leaning heavily on established tropes and occasionally stumbling with its thematic ambitions. Let’s dive into what works, what doesn’t, and whether this continuation is worth your time.
A Shift in Setting, A Lingering Evil
The film cleverly reimagines the core concept of “A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors.” Instead of a psychiatric hospital, the story unfolds around a snowed-in Christian summer camp. This change of scenery provides a claustrophobic atmosphere, amplifying the sense of isolation and dread.
You’ll meet new characters alongside returning faces, including Ernesto (Miguel Mora) and camp supervisor Armando (Demián Bichir). Armando, in particular, serves as a crucial link to the camp’s dark history.Arianna Rivas as Mercedes, Armando’s niece, adds another layer to the unfolding mystery. While attempts to infuse the dialog with Latinx flair are sometimes uneven, Bichir expertly carries the weight of the film’s complex backstory.
Thematic Ambitions and Missed Opportunities
“Black Phone 2” delves into weighty themes, notably the existence of Heaven and Hell and the role of Christian belief. This isn’t new territory for horror – posession films and the “conjuring” universe are built on similar foundations.
However, the film’s exploration feels inconsistent. It initially sets up a compelling critique of religious hypocrisy, only to ultimately revert to a more conventional “good versus evil” narrative.This shift feels like a missed possibility to offer a truly nuanced viewpoint.
Where “Black Phone 2″ Truly Shines: Visual Horror
Director Scott Derrickson excels at delivering visceral, impactful horror. The film boasts stunning practical effects, elevating both the real-world and dream sequences.
Consider this: a scene featuring the ghosts of murdered children from 1957 is a masterclass in creative gore. Imagine a boy’s head sliced diagonally on a windowpane, slithering to the ground, twitching as blood pools around it. Its genuinely disturbing and unforgettable.
Furthermore, Derrickson pays homage to “A Nightmare on elm Street” with inventive body distortions. Characters are spun and flung around like puppets, battling an unseen force within Gwen’s dreams. These sequences are visually arresting and effectively unsettling.
The Echoes of Horror Past
It’s undeniable that “Black Phone 2″ draws heavily from other iconic horror films. Beyond the obvious ”Nightmare on Elm Street” influence, the isolated, snowbound setting instantly evokes “the Shining.”
These references aren’t necessarily a weakness. They’re enjoyable because they tap into established horror tropes that work. However, it prevents the film from achieving true originality. Ultimately, it feels like a well-crafted remix rather than a groundbreaking innovation.
Here’s a speedy breakdown of what you can expect:
* Strong Visuals: Expect genuinely terrifying and creative practical effects.
* Solid Performances: Demián Bichir anchors the film with a compelling performance.
* Familiar Tropes: Be prepared for echoes of classic horror films.
* Thematic Inconsistencies: The film’s exploration of faith feels somewhat underdeveloped.
The Verdict: Good Enough,But Not Groundbreaking
“Black Phone 2” is a worthwhile sequel that delivers on its promise of scares. It’s a well-made horror film with strong performances and impressive visuals.
Tho, it doesn’t transcend its influences. It relies too heavily on established tropes and doesn’t fully realize its thematic potential.
Grade: B-
“Black Phone 2” premiered at Fantastic Fest 2025 and will be released in theaters on Friday, October 17 by Universal Pictures.
Stay Informed:
Want to stay up-to-date on the latest film reviews and critical analysis? Subscribe to indiewire’s In Review newsletter by David Ehrlich for exclusive insights and recommendations. link to Newsletter
