Nativity Scene Sparks Controversy and Archdiocesan Review in Dedham, Massachusetts
A nativity display outside St. Susanna’s Parish in Dedham has ignited a national conversation,prompting a scheduled meeting between the parish priest and the Archbishop of Boston. The scene notably omits the figures of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, suggesting their detention by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
This isn’t the first time St. Susanna’s has used its nativity scene to make a statement. In 2018, the parish depicted baby Jesus in a cage, drawing attention to immigration issues at the time. The current display, unveiled shortly after Thanksgiving, aims to continue fostering dialog around contemporary societal challenges.
A Scene Designed to provoke Discussion
Father Stephen Josoma, the parish priest, explained that the intention behind the display was “to create dialogue around contemporary life.” The absence of the Holy Family is a purposeful artistic choice meant to highlight the plight of families affected by immigration policies.
However, the Archdiocese of Boston has requested the removal of the display.They believe that a church should primarily offer opportunities for prayer and worship, not serve as a platform for divisive political messaging. The Archdiocese also cited church norms prohibiting the use of sacred objects for purposes other than religious devotion.
Reactions and Upcoming Discussions
The display has drawn strong reactions from various corners. Todd Lyons, Director of ICE, condemned the scene as “abhorrent” and accused it of promoting a “hazardous and extremist narrative.”
Archbishop richard Henning has scheduled a meeting with Father Josoma in January to discuss the matter. He stated his intention is to first listen to Father Josoma’s perspective, as the priest requested the meeting.
A Subtle Acknowledgment During Christmas Mass
During Christmas Day Mass at St. Susanna’s, Father Josoma subtly alluded to the controversy. He playfully suggested that if asked about attending Mass at St. Susanna’s, parishioners should simply respond with, “It’s so good to see you!” – a lighthearted acknowledgement of the attention the display has garnered.
This nativity scene underscores the increasing intersection of faith and social justice issues. It highlights how religious institutions are navigating the complexities of political discourse while striving to remain spaces of worship and spiritual reflection. The outcome of the upcoming meeting between the Archbishop and the priest will likely set a precedent for similar expressions within the Archdiocese in the future.
