Finding Solace in the Wild: A Deep Dive into “H is for Hawk” and the Complexities of Grief
“H is for Hawk,” adapted from Helen Macdonald‘s acclaimed memoir, isn’t simply a film about falconry. It’s a profoundly moving exploration of grief, repression, and the unexpected paths we take to navigate loss. This review delves into the film’s strengths, its subtle nuances, and why it resonates so deeply with audiences grappling with their own experiences of bereavement.
The story centers on Helen Macdonald (Essie Davis),a Cambridge-trained historian who,reeling from the sudden death of her father,embarks on the intensely challenging journey of training a goshawk named Mabel. The choice itself is initially puzzling. Why a goshawk, a notoriously difficult bird to manage?
Fellow falconers, like Stu (Sam Spruell), cautioned Helen against it. Yet,Mabel’s seemingly well-behaved nature,despite being a wild predator,only deepens the mystery of Helen’s decision. It’s a decision rooted in something far more profound than a simple hobby.
The Uncomfortable Truths of Mourning
What truly elevates “H is for Hawk” is its unflinching portrayal of grief’s awkwardness. The script, penned by Lowthorpe and Donoghue, masterfully captures the often-comical, sometimes unsettling, ways we attempt to cope with loss.
Consider the scene where Helen informs a restaurant server of her father’s passing, only to be presented with a mountain of desserts. Or the darkly humorous exchange with the funeral director regarding a “themed” coffin. These moments aren’t played for laughs, but rather to highlight the societal discomfort surrounding death and the isolating nature of personal sorrow.
Essie Davis: A Masterclass in Repression
Essie Davis delivers a truly remarkable performance. She embodies Helen’s stiff-upper-lip British reserve with breathtaking subtlety.
davis conveys a wealth of emotion through minute gestures – the almost dismissive way she brushes away tears, treating them as mere inconveniences rather than expressions of deep pain.Her previous collaboration with director lowthorpe on “The Crown” clearly demonstrates a shared understanding of nuanced character work.
A Descent, Not a Fall
As Helen becomes increasingly consumed by Mabel, her life outside of falconry begins to unravel. She neglects her work, distances herself from loved ones, and avoids social interaction.
This isn’t a dramatic collapse, but a gradual slide into depression. The film sensitively portrays this process, but it’s also where it falters slightly.
Pacing and Editing: A Missed Opportunity?
While emotionally resonant, “H is for hawk” feels somewhat baggy. Repetitive scenes and ideas slow the momentum, preventing the film from reaching its full emotional potential. A tighter edit could have distilled the core themes into a more powerful and impactful narrative.
However, this purposeful pacing also mirrors the patience required in falconry itself – and in the grieving process.
A Father’s Legacy and the Power of Memory
Throughout the film, flashbacks to Helen’s happier days with her father are interwoven with the present narrative. These memories are often triggered by seemingly insignificant details – a healed scrape on his arm, the seating arrangement in a car.
Brendan Gleeson’s portrayal of Helen’s father is beautifully understated. He avoids sentimentality, presenting a relatable and flawed human being, rather than an idealized figure. The film frequently uses light to symbolize his presence, often depicting him backlit by a radiant glow.
Mabel: A Mirror to the Soul
The symbolism surrounding Mabel is rich and multifaceted. Is she a stand-in for Helen’s father? A portrayal of her grief? Or perhaps a reflection of Helen herself?
Mabel serves as a constant reminder of mortality and the awe-inspiring beauty of the natural world. It’s a question that lingers long after the credits roll. And, as the film subtly suggests, perhaps we’re all prone to projecting our own emotions onto the creatures around us.
Why “H is for Hawk” Matters
“H is for Hawk” isn’t a film that offers easy answers. It doesn’t provide a neat resolution to Helen’s grief.Instead,it offers a raw,honest,and deeply moving portrayal of a woman finding solace in the wild,and in the challenging,transformative process of learning to live with loss.
If you
