New York City is poised for significant changes in its correctional system as Mayor Zohran Mamdani moves to dismantle the practice of solitary confinement within city jails. This initiative, announced on January 9, 2026, signals a major shift in the city’s approach to incarceration and a commitment to addressing the psychological harms associated with prolonged isolation. The move comes as scrutiny intensifies regarding conditions within facilities like Rikers Island, long criticized for overcrowding and systemic issues.
The Human Cost of isolation: Stories from Those Affected
On Thursday, January 8, 2026, Melquan Thawney, Kayeye Inman, and Quayshawn Smith experienced a freedom many only dream of, walking the streets of New York City as released individuals. Their journeys, though, are inextricably linked to the harsh realities of the city’s jail system, specifically the damaging effects of extended periods in solitary confinement.
Their experiences paint a stark picture of the conditions endured. Smith described the psychological toll, stating, “Being in a box,” it messes with your mental a lot. You’re locked in 23 hours a day, you weren’t getting any commissary. Dinner’s at 4 p.m., the rest of the day you are starving, it’s cold in there sometimes, the heat turns off.”
The lack of basic necessities and the presence of rodents further compounded the dehumanizing experience.
These men, having served time at Rikers Island – a facility consistently plagued by reports of violence and inadequate conditions – are now channeling their experiences into advocacy. They are dedicated to preventing future generations from enduring similar hardships. According to a 2024 report by the new York City Board of Correction,individuals held in solitary confinement are three times more likely to re-offend within three years of release.
“We just have this one thing in common that we want to see change in our community,” Thawney explained, highlighting the shared purpose driving their activism. Inman added, “We’re breaking the norms,” said Inman. “The community norms, which is just as you’re from over here and over here, we got to be at odds. So that’s why we do this. This means together, and we’re leading by example.”
Their work embodies a commitment to unity and positive change.
The news of Mayor Mamdani’s executive order brought a sense of relief. Nick Smith, who first encountered solitary confinement at age 16, expressed optimism, stating, “I think it’s a great step forward,” he said. “For the kids mainly, but for everybody. When you go in that box, it’s like jail inside of jail.”
This sentiment underscores the especially damaging impact of isolation on young people.
Did You Know? the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules) state that solitary confinement should be used only in extraordinary circumstances and for the shortest possible duration.
Navigating the Challenges Ahead
While advocates acknowledge the executive order as a positive step, they caution that it is not the final solution. Concerns remain that solitary confinement could be rebranded under different names, effectively circumventing the intent of the order. Strict oversight and transparent implementation will be crucial to ensure genuine reform.
Thawney emphasized the need for comprehensive support systems, stating, “There should be more programs,” he said. “Whether it’s for anger, substance abuse or whatever it is. Everyone is different.”
Investing in rehabilitation and addressing the root causes of incarceration are essential components of a lasting solution.
The mayor’s administration is expected to present a detailed plan for ending solitary confinement within the next 45 days. This plan will be closely scrutinized by advocates, legal experts, and the public alike.
Pro Tip: Stay informed about local policy changes and advocate for criminal justice reform by contacting your elected officials and supporting organizations working on these issues.
Understanding Solitary Confinement and Its Impact
solitary confinement, also known as restrictive housing, involves isolating prisoners from human contact for 22-24 hours a day. While proponents argue it’s necessary for maintaining order and safety within correctional facilities, a growing body of research demonstrates its severe psychological and physical consequences.These include increased rates of depression,anxiety,psychosis,and self-harm. A 2023 study published in the *American Journal of Public Health* found a significant correlation between time spent in solitary and increased mortality rates post-release.
The use of









