Frankfurt, Germany – A growing concern over organized crime’s involvement in the illegal trade of fluorinated gases (F-gases) is set to take center stage at a science-policy dialogue hosted by Goethe University Frankfurt and the Hessian Ministry for Agriculture and the Environment on April 30, 2026. The conference aims to bridge the gap between scientific research and policy implementation in tackling this emerging form of climate crime.
F-gases, potent greenhouse gases used in refrigeration, air conditioning and heat pumps, are subject to strict regulations under international agreements like the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol and the European Union’s F-Gas Regulation. Despite these controls, a black market for these substances has flourished, driven by high prices and demand, particularly for older, more potent F-gases that are being phased down. This illegal trade undermines climate goals and poses environmental risks due to improper handling and release of these gases into the atmosphere. The increasing sophistication of these criminal networks, and their ability to exploit loopholes in the regulatory framework, is prompting a coordinated response from law enforcement and environmental agencies.
The Rise of Climate Crime and the F-Gas Trade
Organized climate crime, a relatively new field of criminal activity, encompasses a range of illicit behaviors that harm environmental protection efforts. The illegal trade in F-gases is a prime example, alongside illegal logging, wildlife trafficking, and waste dumping. The profitability of these crimes, coupled with the relatively low risk of detection and prosecution, makes them attractive to criminal organizations. The European Commission has identified illegal F-gas trade as a significant threat, estimating that it represents a substantial portion of the overall F-gas market. The upcoming conference in Frankfurt reflects a growing recognition of the demand for a more coordinated and proactive approach to combatting this issue.
The illicit F-gas market operates through various channels, including mislabeling of products, fraudulent documentation, and smuggling across borders. Criminals often exploit differences in regulations between countries, importing F-gases into regions with lax enforcement and then re-exporting them to areas with stricter controls. The complexity of the supply chain and the technical nature of the products make it tough to trace the origin and destination of illegally traded F-gases. The involvement of legitimate businesses, either knowingly or unknowingly, can further complicate investigations.
Experts Convene to Address the Challenge
The April 30th dialogue will bring together a diverse group of experts from law enforcement, academia, industry, and environmental organizations. Holger Buchhold, a public prosecutor from the Frankfurt Public Prosecutor’s Office, will share insights into the legal challenges of prosecuting F-gas related crimes. Professors Christoph Burchard and Joachim Curtius from Goethe University Frankfurt, along with Prof. Dr. Katrin Höffler from Humboldt University of Berlin, will present research on the dynamics of the illegal F-gas trade and its environmental impact. Arnd Lagies, representing the German Refrigerant and Air Conditioning Association (BVKMW) and Chemours, will offer a perspective from the industry, highlighting efforts to promote responsible refrigerant management and prevent illegal activities.
The participation of Juliane Lomb from the German Federal Criminal Police Office (Bundeskriminalamt), though still pending confirmation, is crucial. Her expertise would provide valuable insights into the investigative techniques and challenges faced by law enforcement agencies in tackling organized climate crime. Sophia Stahl from paper trail media, an investigative journalism organization, will likely contribute reporting on the illicit trade networks and their operations. The conference is being organized in collaboration with the Mercator Science-Policy Fellowship Program and the ENGAGEgreen project of the Rhine-Main Universities, underscoring the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration in addressing this complex issue.
The Role of International Cooperation
Combating the illegal F-gas trade requires strong international cooperation. The Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol, which aims to phase down the production and consumption of hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), a type of F-gas, provides a framework for global action. However, effective implementation of the amendment relies on robust enforcement mechanisms and information sharing between countries. Germany, like other nations, is actively working to attract skilled workers to support its environmental protection efforts, including those focused on monitoring and enforcing F-gas regulations.
The European Union has also taken steps to strengthen its F-Gas Regulation, including stricter controls on the placement of F-gases on the market and increased penalties for illegal activities. However, challenges remain in ensuring consistent enforcement across member states and preventing the influx of illegally imported F-gases. The EU is also exploring the use of technologies, such as blockchain, to improve traceability and transparency in the F-gas supply chain.
Looking Ahead: Strengthening Enforcement and Prevention
The science-policy dialogue in Frankfurt represents a critical step towards developing a more effective response to organized climate crime and the illegal F-gas trade. Key areas for discussion will likely include strengthening law enforcement capabilities, enhancing international cooperation, improving refrigerant tracking and tracing systems, and raising awareness among businesses, and consumers. The ZEW (Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research) has been involved in research related to environmental policy, including work with the Hessian Ministry for Environment, Energy, Landscape and Consumer Protection, suggesting a potential source of data and analysis for informing policy decisions. Their annual report may contain relevant insights.
Preventing illegal activities requires a multi-faceted approach that addresses the underlying drivers of the trade. This includes reducing the demand for illegal F-gases by promoting the adoption of climate-friendly alternatives, such as natural refrigerants, and providing incentives for responsible refrigerant management. It also requires strengthening the regulatory framework to close loopholes and increase the cost of illegal activities. A successful strategy will depend on collaboration between governments, industry, and civil society to protect the environment and ensure a sustainable future.
The conference on April 30th is free and open to the public, offering a valuable opportunity to learn more about this critical issue and contribute to the development of effective solutions. Further details about the event, including the agenda and registration information, can be found on the Goethe University Frankfurt website. The next step will be the publication of a summary report detailing the key findings and recommendations from the dialogue, expected in the summer of 2026.
What are your thoughts on the growing threat of climate crime? Share your comments below and help us continue the conversation.
