United Internet’s stock currently trades at a 20% discount to its peers in Germany’s MDAX index, with analysts projecting the company could close this valuation gap by mid-2026 if its core divisions—particularly 1&1, Hosting, and Cloud—deliver consistent revenue growth and margin expansion. The company’s ability to balance these segments will determine whether its shares regain market favor, according to recent financial assessments and analyst reports.
United Internet, Germany’s largest digital services provider, has faced pressure from investors over its stock performance, which has lagged behind competitors like Vodafone and Telefónica despite strong operational metrics in its telecom and cloud businesses. The company’s shares hit a low of €12.50 in early 2024 before stabilizing around €14.10, while its MDAX peers trade at an average premium of 30%. This discrepancy has led analysts to scrutinize whether United Internet’s strategic focus on digital infrastructure—particularly its hosting and cloud divisions—can drive the profitability needed to justify a higher valuation.
Key to this assessment is the performance of 1&1, United Internet’s consumer telecom brand, which accounts for nearly 40% of the company’s total revenue. While 1&1 has shown resilience in Germany’s competitive telecom market—growing its broadband subscriber base by 8% year-over-year in Q1 2024—the segment’s margins remain under pressure due to infrastructure investments and regulatory costs. Meanwhile, United Internet’s Hosting and Cloud division, which includes brands like Strato and IONOS, has emerged as a bright spot, with cloud revenue growing 15% annually and margins approaching 30%, according to the company’s latest earnings report.
Why United Internet’s Stock Discount Persists: The Role of 1&1 and Cloud Growth
The valuation gap between United Internet and its MDAX peers stems from two primary factors: divisional mix and growth expectations. Unlike telecom-focused peers, United Internet derives only about 40% of its revenue from traditional telecom services (via 1&1), with the remainder split between hosting, cloud, and digital advertising. This diversified model has historically insulated the company from telecom-specific risks, but it has also made it harder for analysts to project a clear growth trajectory.
Analysts at Commerzbank and DWS have noted that United Internet’s stock discount reflects skepticism about whether its non-telecom divisions can offset the slower growth in 1&1’s consumer business. “The market is pricing in a scenario where 1&1’s margins compress further, while the cloud and hosting segments may not grow fast enough to compensate,” said Markus Müller, a telecom analyst at DWS, in a recent interview with Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. “This creates a valuation disconnect that could close if the cloud business accelerates.”
United Internet’s cloud division, which includes IONOS and Strato, has been a standout performer, with revenue reaching €1.2 billion in 2023—a 15% increase from the prior year. The division’s profitability has also improved, with operating margins climbing to 28% in Q1 2024, up from 24% a year earlier. This growth has been driven by increased demand for hybrid cloud solutions among small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Europe, a trend that United Internet aims to capitalize on through strategic acquisitions and partnerships.
Key Statistic: United Internet’s cloud revenue grew 15% year-over-year in 2023, with operating margins reaching 28%—outperforming both its telecom and hosting segments. Analysts project this growth could narrow the company’s valuation gap with MDAX peers by 2026 if margins continue to expand.
What Analysts Are Watching: Margin Trends and Regulatory Risks
The outlook for United Internet’s stock hinges on two critical variables: margin trends in 1&1 and regulatory risks in the telecom sector. While 1&1 has maintained its market share in Germany’s broadband market—thanks to aggressive pricing and bundling strategies—its margins have been squeezed by rising fiber-optic deployment costs and regulatory obligations, such as universal service obligations.
Regulatory challenges are a particular concern. In 2023, the German Federal Network Agency (BNetzA) imposed additional requirements on telecom providers to expand rural broadband coverage, which has increased capital expenditures for 1&1. “These regulatory costs are eating into 1&1’s margins, and until they stabilize, the stock will remain under pressure,” said Jürgen Meinert, a telecom equity strategist at Commerzbank.
On the other hand, United Internet’s cloud and hosting divisions appear better positioned to weather regulatory headwinds. The company has invested heavily in automation and AI-driven infrastructure, which has reduced operational costs and improved scalability. For example, IONOS’s AI-powered hosting solutions have reduced customer support costs by 20%, according to internal company data shared in its 2023 sustainability report.
Regulatory Impact: The German Federal Network Agency’s rural broadband mandates have added €150 million in annual costs for 1&1, pressuring margins in the telecom segment. Meanwhile, United Internet’s cloud division has seen cost savings of 20% through AI-driven automation, offsetting some of the regulatory burden.
How United Internet Could Close the Valuation Gap by 2026
Analysts project that United Internet could narrow its MDAX valuation gap by mid-2026 if three conditions are met:
- Cloud revenue growth accelerates: If IONOS and Strato can grow cloud revenue at 18–20% annually, the division could contribute 35% of United Internet’s total revenue by 2026, improving overall margins.
- 1&1 stabilizes margins: Regulatory costs must plateau, and the company must achieve €50 million in annual savings from its fiber-optic network optimization program.
- Acquisitions drive scale: United Internet has signaled interest in acquiring smaller European cloud providers to expand its footprint, which could unlock additional synergies.
In a recent note, Berenberg Bank analysts projected that if United Internet achieves these milestones, its stock could re-rate to a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 18x—up from its current 14x—by 2026. “The market is undervaluing United Internet’s cloud potential,” wrote Sebastian Schaefer, a telecom analyst at Berenberg. “If the company can execute on its cloud strategy while managing 1&1’s costs, the stock could be a compelling buy.”
Analyst Consensus: Berenberg Bank estimates United Internet’s stock could reach €18–€20 by 2026 if cloud revenue grows 18% annually and 1&1’s margins stabilize, narrowing the MDAX valuation gap.
What Happens Next: Key Dates and Investor Checkpoints
Investors will closely monitor several upcoming developments to assess United Internet’s progress:
- Q2 2024 Earnings (August 15, 2024): United Internet will report its second-quarter results, with a focus on cloud revenue growth and 1&1’s margin trends.
- IONOS Cloud Expansion (H2 2024): The company plans to announce new AI-driven cloud products, which could further boost its competitive position.
- Regulatory Updates (Q4 2024): The German Federal Network Agency is expected to release its 2024 broadband expansion plan, which will impact 1&1’s cost structure.
- Potential Acquisitions (2025): United Internet has hinted at exploring acquisitions in the European cloud market, which could accelerate its growth trajectory.
The next major catalyst for United Internet’s stock will be its full-year 2024 earnings report, scheduled for February 20, 2025. This report will provide a clearer picture of whether the company’s cloud division can offset the challenges in its telecom business, potentially unlocking further re-rating in its stock price.
For investors: United Internet’s stock discount presents both risk and opportunity. While the company’s cloud division shows strong growth potential, the telecom segment’s regulatory pressures remain a wild card. The next 12 months will be critical in determining whether United Internet can bridge the valuation gap with its MDAX peers.
Share your thoughts in the comments below or follow World Today Journal for updates on United Internet’s strategic developments.
Related reading