Rikers Island Visitation: A System Failing Families adn Inmates – and How to Fix It
For years,families and advocates have voiced concerns about the arduous and frequently enough dehumanizing experience of visiting loved ones incarcerated on rikers Island. A recent investigation by the New York City Council‘s Committees on Oversight and Investigations and Criminal Justice confirms these concerns, revealing a system plagued by excessive wait times, inconsistent procedures, and a lack of basic consideration for visitors. This report details the findings and outlines critical recommendations for immediate advancement,emphasizing the vital role family connections play in rehabilitation and community stability.
The Reality of Visiting Rikers: A Deep dive into Systemic Issues
The investigation paints a stark picture of the challenges faced by individuals attempting to maintain contact with those in custody. The issues aren’t isolated incidents; they represent systemic failures within the Department of Correction (DOC) that demand urgent attention.
Here’s a breakdown of the key problems identified:
* Excessive Time Commitment: visiting Rikers is not a fast undertaking. Data reveals visits routinely consume an entire day. Visitors report spending over five hours for a single hour-long visit.A Council investigator experienced a visit lasting from 12:30 PM to 7:00 PM. DOC’s own internal study corroborates this, showing an average visit duration of four-and-a-half hours. This notable time burden disproportionately impacts those with work, childcare, or other commitments, effectively limiting access for many.
* Dehumanizing Wait Conditions: Visitors are frequently left waiting for extended periods – frequently enough exceeding an hour, including 45 minutes after visiting hours begin – outside the Benjamin Ward Visit Center with no seating, access to restrooms, or readily available drinking water. These conditions are unacceptable and demonstrate a disregard for the basic needs and dignity of individuals exercising their right to maintain family ties.
* Lack of Clear Details & Inconsistent procedures: The information provided by DOC, both online and on-site, is inadequate and often misleading.visitors consistently report encountering varying procedures with each visit, leading to confusion and frustration.This lack of transparency and consistency creates unneeded stress and hinders a smooth visiting process.
* Arbitrary Dress Code Enforcement: Visitors are routinely denied access due to attire, despite DOC’s own guidelines mandating the provision of cover-up garments.Investigators witnessed multiple instances of individuals being turned away without being offered this option, directly contradicting established policy. This practice is not only frustrating but also actively prevents legitimate visits.
* Unhelpful and Inconsistent Staff Interactions: Interviewees consistently described DOC staff as unhelpful and inconsistent in applying rules. This lack of clear guidance and support further exacerbates the challenges visitors face.
Why This Matters: The Importance of Family Connections in Corrections
Maintaining strong family connections is not merely a matter of compassion; it’s a critical component of accomplished rehabilitation and reduced recidivism. Research consistently demonstrates that individuals who maintain ties with their families while incarcerated are more likely to successfully reintegrate into society upon release. Denying or hindering these connections undermines the very goals of the correctional system.
As Council Member Gale Brewer, chair of the Committee on Oversight and Investigations, stated, “This investigation makes clear what families have been saying for years: visiting a loved one on Rikers is an exhausting, confusing, and often dehumanizing ordeal.”
A Path Forward: Recommendations for Immediate Action
The Council’s investigation doesn’t simply identify problems; it offers concrete, actionable recommendations to improve the visiting process at Rikers Island. These recommendations are grounded in best practices and a commitment to treating visitors with dignity and respect.
- Accelerate Process Assessment & Implement Online Scheduling: DOC must prioritize a thorough assessment of the entire visiting process, publicly release its findings, and immediately implement improvements. Crucially, this includes the swift implementation of a user-amiable online scheduling system to reduce wait times and improve predictability.
- Improve Visitor Amenities: Addressing the basic needs of visitors is paramount. DOC should immediately add benches and clearly marked signage directing visitors to restrooms near the outdoor waiting area, adhering to the Board of Correction’s minimum standards.
- Standardize Dress Code Enforcement: DOC must clarify its dress code policy in the Visit Procedures Directive,training materials,and a memo to all staff. The policy should explicitly state that dress code compliance is assessed once per jail and that any visitor willing to wear a provided cover-up garment should be permitted to proceed with their visit.
- Enhance Information Accessibility: DOC must update its website and relocate on-site signage to provide clear, accurate, and comprehensive information about the visiting process.This includes detailed instructions, frequently asked questions, and a clear explanation of prohibited items.
- Invest in Staff Training & Explore Volunteer Support: DOC should evaluate and enhance
Related reading