Drew Allar and Will Howard are both vying for a role in the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback plans as the team navigates a transitional period at the position. Their connection runs deeper than just competing for snaps — both players share Pennsylvania roots and have faced similar scrutiny as they aim to establish themselves in the NFL. Allar, a Penn State product, was selected by the Steelers in the third round of the 2026 NFL Draft, while Howard, a former Ohio State quarterback, entered the league as a fifth-round pick in 2025. Their journeys have drawn attention from local media and fans alike, particularly given the state’s strong ties to both college programs.
The battle between Allar and Howard reflects broader questions about the Steelers’ quarterback strategy moving into the 2026 season. With no clear starter established on the roster, the team has leaned on veterans like Mason Rudolph while evaluating younger options. Allar’s selection in the draft signaled a commitment to developing future talent, though his rookie year is expected to be more about learning than immediate impact. Meanwhile, Howard has remained in the mix as a developmental prospect, having shown flashes during limited action in his first season. The dynamic between the two has been framed by analysts as less about direct competition and more about how each fits into the team’s long-term vision.
Media commentary has highlighted the contrasting narratives surrounding the two quarterbacks. Mark Madden, a Pittsburgh-based media personality, publicly urged the Steelers to draft Allar and release Howard, arguing that Howard’s ceiling is that of an NFL backup while Allar possesses starter potential. Madden cited scouting reports from NFL.com that described Allar as resembling a prospect “assembled in a quarterback factory,” praising his physical tools and upside. However, other voices within the Steelers organization have expressed confidence in Howard’s development, particularly given his experience in high-pressure college games at Ohio State and his familiarity with the team’s offensive system.
Fantasy football analysts have also weighed in on Allar’s potential value, noting that while he is unlikely to see significant playing time in 2026, his draft position makes him a stash option in dynasty and superflex leagues. The Steelers’ supporting cast — including receivers DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr., running backs Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle, and tight ends Pat Freiermuth and Darnell Washington — has been viewed as a positive environment for a young quarterback’s growth. Still, the possibility of Aaron Rodgers returning for another season adds uncertainty to Allar’s immediate role, potentially pushing his starting opportunity further into the future.
Both Allar and Howard have drawn interest not only for their on-field abilities but also for their off-field connections to Pennsylvania. Allar grew up in the state and played his college football at Penn State, where he became a fan favorite for his poise and leadership. Howard, though he played college football at Ohio State, has maintained ties to the region through training and offseason workouts in Western Pennsylvania. These local connections have resonated with Steelers fans, who often prioritize players with regional ties when evaluating roster decisions.
As the 2026 offseason progresses, the Steelers’ quarterback situation remains fluid. The team has not announced any definitive plans regarding Howard’s roster status, nor have they indicated when Allar might be expected to compete for a starting role. Training camp and preseason performances will likely play a key role in shaping the depth chart, with both young quarterbacks aiming to demonstrate readiness for increased responsibility. For now, the focus remains on development, with the organization balancing short-term needs against long-term investments in the quarterback position.
Steelers fans and analysts will continue to monitor how Allar and Howard progress through the offseason program and into training camp. Their paths, while distinct, reflect a shared goal: earning a place in Pittsburgh’s quarterback future. Whether that means one emerges as a starter, both contribute in different roles, or neither secures a long-term spot, their journey will remain a point of interest for those following the team’s evolution.
For the latest updates on the Steelers’ quarterback competition and roster moves, readers can follow the team’s official channels and trusted sports news outlets covering training camp developments and preseason performances.
Related reading