Los Angeles, CA – In a victory for video game preservation and a testament to the power of collective action, the obscure 1999 Japanese PC game Cookie’s Bustle has been freed from a years-long campaign to erase it from the internet. The game, known for its bizarre and undefinable narrative – involving a five-year-old girl from Modern Jersey entering a global sports competition that spirals into international conflict – had grow the target of aggressive copyright claims, hindering research and access to this unique piece of gaming history. The Video Game History Foundation (VGHF) successfully challenged these claims, securing the game’s online presence and ensuring its legacy isn’t lost to digital obscurity.
The battle over Cookie’s Bustle began in 2022, when an individual identified as Brandon White, operating through the company Graceware, began issuing Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedown notices to websites and content creators hosting material related to the game. These requests targeted everything from gameplay videos and fan art to simple mentions of the title, creating a chilling effect on discussion and preservation efforts. The VGHF itself became a target after donating a rare physical copy of Cookie’s Bustle, received from multimedia researcher Misty De Méo, to its collection and attempting to document it digitally. The Foundation’s archive page dedicated to the game was hit with a copyright strike, disrupting access to this important resource.
A Campaign of Eradication
The actions of Graceware were particularly perplexing given the game’s age and relative obscurity. As Phil Salvador, the VGHF’s library director, explained, “Although Graceware’s actions against us were incredibly disruptive, we saw this as an opportunity to receive to the bottom of what was happening.” The VGHF launched an investigation, uncovering a pattern of spurious claims and a network of firms used by White to pursue his campaign. White seemingly attempted to leverage the Association for UK Interactive Entertainment (Ukie) to enforce his claims, even misspelling his company name as “Gracewear” in his Ukie membership details, according to the VGHF’s findings.
The VGHF recognized that confronting Ukie directly would be crucial to halting the takedown requests. When the archive entry for Cookie’s Bustle was restored, Ukie was unable to prompt the Foundation’s host to remove it again. Mumith Ali of Ukie then contacted the VGHF, requesting that they ask Graceware to provide proof of ownership. Crucially, Graceware was unable to provide any legitimate documentation establishing their rights to the game.
Unraveling the Mystery
The VGHF’s investigation revealed that White had been utilizing automated copyright services, such as Web Capio, to issue the DMCA claims. However, the core issue remained: White had no demonstrable ownership of Cookie’s Bustle. The game’s original creator remains unknown, leaving it in a legal status described as “orphaned” – meaning the copyright holder cannot be identified. This does not equate to public domain, but it does mean that any claim of ownership requires substantial proof, which White failed to provide. The VGHF’s success hinged on their willingness to challenge the claims and demand evidence, ultimately exposing the lack of legal basis for White’s actions.
The Significance of Preservation
The case of Cookie’s Bustle highlights the growing challenges faced by video game preservationists. As games age and become more obscure, they are often vulnerable to being lost to time, either through physical decay or legal disputes. The VGHF’s mission is to safeguard these important cultural artifacts, ensuring they remain accessible for research, education, and enjoyment. The organization’s work extends beyond simply archiving games; it involves documenting their history, understanding their cultural context, and advocating for policies that support preservation efforts. The foundation’s digital archive now includes documentation of the game’s packaging and materials, alongside the gameplay video recorded by community member sebmal, providing valuable resources for researchers.
The fight over Cookie’s Bustle also underscores the potential for abuse within the DMCA system. The ease with which takedown notices can be issued, coupled with the limited resources available to those defending against them, creates an environment where copyright claims can be used to stifle legitimate expression and hinder access to information. This case serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of due diligence and the require for greater accountability in the enforcement of copyright law. The VGHF’s victory is not just a win for Cookie’s Bustle, but for the broader principles of open access and cultural preservation.
What’s Next for Cookie’s Bustle?
With the copyright claims resolved, Cookie’s Bustle is now freely available for exploration and appreciation. The YouTube account ClassicsOfGame has reposted the previously removed videos, and the game can once again be streamed and discussed without fear of censorship. However, the mystery surrounding the game’s creator remains unsolved. The VGHF continues to investigate the game’s origins, hoping to uncover the identity of the individual or team responsible for this unique and enigmatic title.
The VGHF’s success in this case sets a precedent for future preservation efforts. By demonstrating a willingness to challenge questionable copyright claims and advocate for the rights of researchers and enthusiasts, the Foundation has sent a clear message that it will not allow valuable cultural heritage to be suppressed. The organization plans to continue its work documenting and preserving video games, ensuring that these important artifacts are available for generations to come. The VGHF is currently focused on expanding its digital archive and developing new tools and resources to support game preservation initiatives.
The story of Cookie’s Bustle is a reminder that even the most obscure and unconventional creations can hold significant cultural value. It’s a testament to the dedication of preservationists and the power of community to protect our shared digital heritage. The game, once on the brink of being erased from existence, is now thriving, thanks to the efforts of those who refused to let it be forgotten.
The VGHF continues to monitor the situation and will provide updates on its website, https://gamehistory.org/, as new information becomes available. Readers interested in supporting the VGHF’s work can find information on donations and volunteer opportunities on their website. Share your thoughts on this remarkable story in the comments below.
Worth a look