New Legislation Aims to Separate insurance and Healthcare ownership
A important shift in healthcare regulation could be on the horizon. A newly proposed bill, the “Patients Over Profits Act,” seeks to prevent insurance companies from directly owning healthcare providers who bill Medicare Parts B and C. This move is designed to address growing concerns about rising costs and potential conflicts of interest within the healthcare system.
What Does the Bill Propose?
The core of the legislation focuses on restructuring the relationship between insurers and providers. Specifically,it would:
* Prohibit Future Acquisitions: Insurance companies would be legally barred from purchasing physician practices,home health agencies,hospices,and other providers reimbursed through Medicare.
* Mandate Divestitures: Insurers currently owning these types of provider groups would be required to sell them off.
* Restrict Medicare Advantage Contracts: The bill would prevent the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) from contracting with Medicare Advantage plans that also own provider businesses.
Why is This Happening Now?
Lawmakers are responding to a trend of increasing consolidation within the healthcare industry.The spotlight is especially on large insurers like UnitedHealth Group (UNH), which has recently acquired major home health and hospice providers, including Amedisys and LHC Group.
These acquisitions,totaling billions of dollars,have raised questions about potential anti-competitive practices and their impact on patient care and costs.As Representative Pat Ryan (D-N.Y.) stated,the goal is to “build something better,where every American is able to get the care they deserve at a price they can afford.”
Key Acquisitions Driving the Debate
To understand the scale of the issue, consider these recent transactions:
* Amedisys: UnitedHealth Group‘s Optum subsidiary completed the acquisition of Amedisys in August 2024 for approximately $3.3 billion. this followed a legal challenge from the Department of Justice, ultimately resolved through a settlement.
* LHC Group: In 2023, UnitedHealth Group also acquired LHC Group, another large home health and hospice provider, for $5.4 billion.
These deals demonstrate a clear pattern of insurers expanding their control over the direct delivery of healthcare services.
Who Can Enforce the New Rules?
If the ”Patients Over Profits Act” becomes law, several entities would have the authority to enforce its provisions. These include:
* The Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
* State Attorneys General
* The HHS Office of the Inspector General
* The U.S. Department of Justice
These bodies could initiate civil lawsuits against insurers failing to comply with the divestiture requirements.
What Does This Mean for You?
This legislation, if passed, could have several implications for patients and the healthcare landscape:
* Potential for Lower Costs: By separating insurance and provider ownership, the bill aims to reduce the incentive for insurers to prioritize profits over patient care, possibly leading to lower healthcare costs.
* Increased Competition: Divestitures could foster greater competition among healthcare providers, potentially improving quality and access to care.
* Greater Transparency: The bill seeks to address concerns about a lack of transparency in healthcare pricing and decision-making.
The Road Ahead
Currently, the “Patients Over Profits Act” exists as separate bills in the Senate and House. Its success will depend on navigating the legislative process and gaining bipartisan support. However, the growing scrutiny of healthcare consolidation suggests a strong momentum for change.
Stay informed about this developing story and how it might impact yoru healthcare experience.
Sources:
* Patients Over Profits Act (Senate): https://www.merkley.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/Patients-Over-Profits-Act.pdf
* Home Health Care News: https://homehealthcarenews.com/2025/09/newly-proposed-bill-would-block-insurers-from-acquiring-home-health-providers-spur-divestitures/
Related reading