#Index #Culture #Shocking #claims #Péter #Nádas #didnt #win #prestigious #award
Issue 22 of Die Zeit printed an article concerning the Haus der Kulturen der Welt (HKW), or House of World Cultures, awarding a considerable literary prize of 35,000 euros, revealing that ideology is extra vital than literary high quality. When awarding an award – write prae.hu.
Two writers – Juliane Liebert and Ronya Othmann – We spoke about how within the spring of 2023 they independently turned a part of the seven-member jury for the worldwide literary prize awarded yearly by the Haus der Kulturen der Welt (HKW – House of World Cultures) in Berlin. Since 2009, this prestigious prize of 35,000 euros has been awarded to works of contemporary worldwide literature and their first German translations, with the writer receiving 20,000 euros and the translator receiving 15,000 euros.
The organizers have clearly formulated the evaluation features, in response to which purposes shall be judged on the standard of their books.
When assessing purposes, we don’t exclude publishers, editors, authors, translators, nationality, ethnicity, political or spiritual views and exclude bias.
– The analysis standards are specified within the accompanying doc.
However, within the technique of confirming the nominations, the scoring was utterly improper and was a parody. Donmi Choi DMZ Colony (DMZ Colony) Translated by Uljana Wolf and Mohamed Mbougar Sarr People’s most secret reminiscences His works translated by Holger Fock and Sabine Müller every obtained 5 factors. Maria Stepanova Unclothed women / Mädchen ohne Kleider (women with out garments), Eva Vieznaviec What are you searching for, Wolf? (What are you searching for, Wolf?) is Mariette Navarro Über die See(About the ocean) 4 factors every, Veronica Gerber Bicecci Leere Menge (approx. empty crowd) obtained a rating of three, and the opposite 4 authors obtained a rating of two every.
However, one of many jurors disagreed with the choice. She could not deal with the truth that the books that every obtained two stars included three black girls, who are actually excluded, and a white French girl was a finalist, she mentioned.
Afterwards, he withdrew his vote from Frenchman Navarro, adopted by a number of different jurors. At one level, it was additionally raised that Mariette Navarro’s downside was that she was a ‘French white girl.’ The jury voted 4 to three to switch the shortlist.
No one can examine to Péter Nádas, however he’s white.
The judges’ determination ensured that Cherie Jones, whose e-book had beforehand been described by some as “violent porn” and “Netflix-style”, may enter the highest six. However, there was additionally a fourth writer who obtained two votes, particularly Péter Nádas, whose e-book had beforehand been categorized as a masterpiece by the jury.
The jury instantly discovered themselves debating which e-book must be changed by French writer Péter Nádas. horror story According to many, his books are undoubtedly one of the best, however Nádas is a privileged white writer beloved by information reporters. O. Ronya mentioned that Péter Nádas got here from a Jewish household, spent a long time in socialism, and that his life wouldn’t be very joyful now in Viktor Orbán’s Hungary. O. Ronya felt it was disagreeable to have to say these info as a result of the standard of the e-book was not vital, however he nonetheless felt compelled to take action.
Nádas is a greater author, however politically I’ve to go along with Cherie Jones. The three judges, earlier than and after, informed Ronya O. that Nádas’s books have been one of the best, that nobody may match them, however that he was a really completed, white man who was liked by journalists. Anyway, Hungarian is a generally acknowledged language.
The ultimate jury couldn’t determine. “It is obvious that Nadas is a greater author and has written higher books,” he mentioned, however “it made me really feel higher when Jürgen Cauwe (one of many publishers and editors of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung) was nominated on the identical time.” “I do know what it’s like,” he added. Then he at all times wins.” “Then would not Jurgen Kaube be a greater author and write a greater e-book?” Juliane L. could not assist however reply this query, and the choose jumped up and mentioned, “I personally haven’t any cause to be upset. “As a white girl, you don’t have anything to say right here anyway!” She then voted for Cherie Jones.
Sorry, I like literature. But politics are extra vital
The different choose was Juliane L.
The winner choice was additionally a multitude.
Two judges additionally reported this problem to HKW, which was later resolved by increasing the shortlist and including two extra works to the six chosen within the first spherical. Yes, however within the course of of choosing the winner, outdated issues resurfaced and beliefs additionally got here to the fore on the expense of professionalism.
Although it was decided which writers deserved the award, the works of black Senegalese writers have been typically translated by white folks, whereas white folks have been typically unable to translate black writers. A black writer used the n-word to precise discrimination towards his character, however some jurors mentioned white translators have been unable to copy it. In the top, regardless of the “n” phrase and white translators, Mohamed Mbougar Sarr emerged the winner.
Even if judges award awards primarily based on literary standards, when a queer, immigrant or different marginalized author wins, it’s typically mentioned that it’s not due to his work however due to his id, in response to two outraged judges. These detrimental phenomena are additional exacerbated by practices like these skilled by the HKW judges. Moreover, it additionally harms these authors, say Juliane Liebert and Ronya Othmann.
(Cover photograph: Kossuth Prize-winning writer Péter Nádas on the terrace of Jelenkor Kiadó’s Budapest workplace, April 4, 2017. Photo: Zoltán Balogh / MTI)
Follow Index on Facebook too!
