MR. Band Dispute: alan po’s Claims and Ronny‘s Response to “Forest” Controversy
A long-simmering dispute between former MR. vocalist Alan Po (布志綸) and current member Ronny (黎澤恩) has resurfaced, centering around the band’s hit song “Forest” (森林) and the distribution of songwriting credits. The conflict has spilled into the public eye as the band prepares for a concert featuring thier classic songs.
Alan Po’s Claims:
Alan Po recently revealed in an interview that he felt his contributions to the band, notably his songwriting, were unfairly distributed.He specifically stated that he wrote a notable number of songs, but didn’t receive due recognition. He also addressed concerns about the upcoming concert, clarifying that the performance of “Forest” would not be purely instrumental, and that all four members would take turns singing.He emphasized that the vocals on “Forest” are undeniably his, comparing the situation to the iconic song “Sea and Sky” (海闊天空) being attributed to Beyond. He offered an apology if his statements caused any offense or sensitivity.
Ronny’s Response & “Forest” Clarification:
Ronny responded to Po’s claims during his own interview, offering a more measured and defensive perspective. He explained that the band’s initial statement regarding ”Forest” was intended to clarify that the concert would feature vocal performances, addressing concerns that it would be a purely instrumental show. He drew a parallel to “sea and Sky” and Beyond,stating that it’s undeniable Alan po’s voice is on the track.
However, Ronny refused to directly address Po’s accusations regarding the distribution of songwriting credits. he stated that responding would require presenting substantial evidence,and the band prefers to address the situation through their music,maintaining a “Mr.” attitude.
Potential for Reconciliation?
Regarding the possibility of a future collaboration with Alan Po,Ronny was noncommittal. He revealed that discussions had taken place previously but were unsuccessful. He expressed reluctance to raise false hopes, stating he couldn’t definitively say a reunion would happen, and didn’t want to make promises he couldn’t keep.He also indicated that the current climate isn’t conducive to a reunion.
Key Takeaways:
* Songwriting Dispute: A core issue is Alan Po’s feeling of being shortchanged regarding credit for his songwriting contributions to MR.’s success.
* “Forest” Controversy: The band sought to clarify that the song would be sung during the concert, not performed as an instrumental piece, and acknowledged Alan Po’s vocals.
* No Immediate Reconciliation: Despite past discussions, a reunion between Alan Po and MR. appears unlikely in the near future.
* “Music Will Speak”: MR.intends to address the controversy through their music rather than engaging in a prolonged public debate.
This situation highlights the complexities of band dynamics, creative ownership, and the lasting impact of past grievances. The public response and the band’s future actions will be closely watched as this dispute continues to unfold.
Keep reading