“Death by Lightning”: A Sharp, Though Rushed, Examination of Garfield’s Assassination
MGM+’s Death by Lightning isn’t your typical historical drama.It’s a darkly comedic,surprisingly poignant limited series focusing on the assassination of President James A. Garfield and the unraveling psyche of his would-be killer,Charles Guiteau. While the series occasionally stumbles in its pacing, it delivers compelling performances and a unique perspective on a little-explored moment in American history.
This review dives deep into what makes death by Lightning work, where it falters, and why it’s worth your time.
A Stellar Supporting Cast Elevates the Narrative
The strength of Death by lightning lies in its supporting players. Nick Offerman, in particular, shines as Chester arthur, Garfield’s Vice President. He masterfully portrays Arthur as a man underestimated, a “blunt instrument” who may possess a hidden depth.
you’ll find yourself captivated by Offerman’s performance, which subtly echoes his iconic Ron Swanson from Parks and recreation, but with a heartbreaking undercurrent.It’s a performance that deserves serious Emmy consideration.
beyond Offerman, the series benefits from:
* tim Whitford as a perpetually bemused observer of American politics.
* Shea Whigham as a disruptive force in a world of polite society.
* Strong turns from Vondie Curtis-Hall as Frederick Douglass and Barry Shabaka Henley as Blanche Bruce.
these actors consistently deliver, making even brief appearances memorable.
Historical Figures & Missed Opportunities
The series attempts to weave in other important historical figures, like Douglass, Bruce, and Kate Chase Sprague. However, their inclusion feels somewhat underdeveloped. Sprague, in particular, feels shortchanged, lacking the depth her historical role deserves.
A particularly baffling choice? Casting Andor breakout Kyle Soller as Robert Todd Lincoln, Garfield’s Secretary of War, and then giving him no lines of dialog. It begs the question: was this material intended for a longer season that was ultimately cut?
A Rushed Climax & The Tragedy of Garfield’s Death
Death by Lightning builds towards the certain confrontation between Garfield and Guiteau. However, the series then rushes thru Garfield’s agonizingly slow death.
Historically, Garfield’s death took 2.5 months, a period marked by cutting-edge (for the time) medical interventions.The series glosses over this crucial period, focusing rather on the immediate aftermath of the shooting.Zeljko Ivanek delivers a suitably frustrating performance as Dr. Bliss, but the potential for exploring the medical innovations of the era is largely untapped.
Similarly, Guiteau’s imprisonment and trial feel truncated, failing to fully capture the bizarre spectacle they were in reality.
Despite Flaws, A Compelling Watch
Despite these shortcomings, Death by Lightning remains a compelling and frequently enough darkly funny series. The first three hours are particularly strong, establishing a unique tone and introducing a cast of captivating characters.
The show’s greatest strength is its willingness to explore the psychological complexities of its characters, particularly Arthur and Guiteau. You’ll find yourself questioning your assumptions about these historical figures and pondering the motivations behind their actions.
The Verdict: Worth Your Time, Especially for Offerman’s Performance
Death by Lightning isn’t perfect. It’s a series of missed opportunities, particularly in its final act. Though, the strong performances, unique perspective, and darkly comedic tone make it a worthwhile watch.
And, frankly, Nick Offerman’s performance is reason enough to tune in. Don’t let him be snubbed for an Emmy again. you’ll be humming “The Ballad of Guiteau” long after the credits roll.
Where to Watch: MGM+
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars.
Worth a look