New York residents enrolled in individual market health insurance plans have until July 17, 2026, to submit public comments regarding proposed premium rate increases for the 2027 plan year. Insurance carriers operating on the New York State of Health marketplace have requested an average premium increase of 21%, a move that could significantly impact household budgets across the state, according to data from the New York Department of Financial Services (DFS).
The DFS, which oversees the state’s prior approval process, invites consumer feedback to evaluate whether these requested hikes are justified. This regulatory review serves as a critical check on insurance costs, as the state must balance carrier solvency with the affordability of coverage for New Yorkers. Historically, the department has frequently approved lower increases than those initially requested by insurers.
Understanding the Rate Review Process
Every year, health insurance companies must submit their proposed premium rates to the New York Department of Financial Services for review before they can be implemented. This “prior approval” system is designed to ensure that premiums are not excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory. The process provides a 30-day window for public input, which begins five days after the proposed rates are officially released by the DFS.
State regulators analyze the financial filings from each carrier, taking into account medical inflation, projected utilization of healthcare services, and administrative costs. Consumer comments play a role in this transparency-focused process, as they provide regulators with real-world context regarding the potential financial burden on policyholders. For the 2027 cycle, the proposed increases vary by carrier, ranging from as low as 1% to as high as 52%, according to official filings monitored by state advocates.
Historical Context of Premium Adjustments
The state’s track record in curbing requested increases suggests a consistent regulatory trend. Over the past three years, the DFS has intervened to limit the final approved rates. In 2024, the state approved average premium increases of 14%. In 2025, that figure was set at 13%, and in 2026, the state-approved increase dropped to 7%, according to records maintained by the New York State of Health marketplace.
This year’s request for a 21% average increase represents a significant jump from the previous year’s approved rate. If approved as requested, the average New Yorker could face an annual premium hike of approximately $2,065, or an additional $172 in monthly costs. These figures highlight the stakes for individual market participants who must navigate rising expenses for essential services like housing, transportation, and groceries alongside their healthcare premiums.
How to Submit a Public Comment
Consumers who wish to participate in the rate review process can submit their feedback directly through the New York Department of Financial Services online portal at https://myportal.dfs.ny.gov/web/prior-approval/submit-a-comment. The submission process requires specific information found on an insurance card or the official plan letter notice sent by the carrier.
To complete the submission, users must select their insurance company, the type of plan held, and whether the policy is individual or group. The comment section does not require formal legal language; concise, direct statements regarding the financial impact of the proposed increase are often the most effective. According to consumer advocacy guidelines, including specific details about why health insurance is essential—such as access to prescription drugs or preventative care—can help regulators understand the practical consequences of the proposed hikes.
A suggested template for comments includes:
- The name of the insurance carrier.
- The specific percentage increase requested by that carrier.
- The estimated annual cost increase.
- A brief explanation of how this financial burden would force a reduction in other essential spending, such as childcare or housing.
What Happens Next
Following the July 17th deadline, the Department of Financial Services will continue its internal review of the carrier filings. The department is expected to issue its final decisions on the 2027 rates later in the year, well in advance of the open enrollment period. This timeline ensures that consumers have clarity on their potential costs before they are required to renew or select a new plan for the upcoming year.
Advocacy organizations, including Health Care For All New York (HCFANY), are expected to release their own analyses of the carrier applications in the coming weeks. Residents are encouraged to monitor the DFS website and local health policy news for updates regarding finalized rates and any public hearings that may be scheduled as part of the approval process. Engaging in this process remains the primary avenue for policyholders to influence the final cost of their coverage.
Keep reading