The san Francisco Promise: Reclaiming the UN Charter‘s Path to Global Constitutionalism
The United Nations, conceived in the aftermath of global conflict, stands at a critical juncture. While its foundational principles remain vital, the organization’s structure - especially the power dynamics within the Security Council – increasingly struggles to address 21st-century challenges. A potential pathway to meaningful reform, however, lies within a largely forgotten clause of the UN charter: Article 109(3), often referred to as the “San Francisco Promise.” This article, representing a commitment to Charter review and potential amendment, offers a unique opportunity to constitutionalize the United Nations and move towards a more democratic and effective system of global governance.
Understanding the San Francisco Promise
During the drafting of the UN Charter, a key point of contention revolved around the veto power held by the five permanent members of the Security Council (the P5: China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom, and the United States). Recognizing the potential for deadlock and inequity, a compromise was reached. Article 109(3) stipulated that the Charter would be subject to review ten years after the UN’s inception - a provision intended to allow for amendments and address any shortcomings revealed in practice.
This ”San Francisco Promise” was activated in 1955, initiating a review conference. However, the process was ultimately stalled and the promise largely abandoned, overshadowed by Cold War tensions and a lack of sustained political will. Despite this historical setback,the legally valid review conference envisioned in Article 109(3) remains a viable mechanism for initiating a process of constitutional advancement for the UN.
Why a UN Constitution?
The current UN Charter, while foundational, functions more as a treaty than a constitution. A true constitution would establish a clearer framework for global governance, addressing critical issues such as:
* Security Council Reform: Mitigating the impact of the veto power and ensuring more equitable depiction.
* Accountability and Openness: Strengthening mechanisms for holding the UN and its agencies accountable.
* Global Challenges: Providing a robust legal framework for addressing transnational issues like climate change, pandemics, and economic instability.
* Human Rights: Solidifying and expanding the protection of essential human rights globally.
By establishing a constitutional framework, the UN could evolve from a primarily intergovernmental organization to a more effective instrument of global governance, capable of fulfilling the ambitious objectives outlined in the UN Charter’s preamble – namely, to “save succeeding generations from the scourge of war.”
The Work of Dr.S.M. Sharei and the Center for united Nations Constitutional Research (CUNCR)
Leading the charge in advocating for the reactivation of the San Francisco Promise is Dr. S.M. Sharei, founding Executive Director and President of the Center for United Nations Constitutional Research (CUNCR). Dr.Sharei’s extensive expertise in public international law and the UN Charter has positioned him as a pivotal figure in this movement.
His research, culminating in the book The Future in the Past: Reconstructing Article 109(3) of the UN Charter Towards The san Francisco Promise to Constitutionalise the United Nations and International law, meticulously details the legal basis and practical pathways for utilizing Article 109(3) to initiate a constitutional review process. Dr.Sharei’s work demonstrates that the legal framework for UN change already exists; what is lacking is the political will to implement it.
Beyond his academic contributions, Dr.Sharei has a long-standing history of activism focused on global governance. His background is remarkably interdisciplinary, holding a PhD and LLM in International Law, alongside degrees in Computer Science and Applied Economics and Management. This diverse skillset informs CUNCR’s holistic approach to global governance challenges.
CUNCR’s initiatives extend beyond research, encompassing:
* Climate Justice, Democracy and Governance Series: Fostering dialog and collaboration between academics, policymakers, and youth activists.
* Youth Climate Ambassador (YCA) Program: Empowering young leaders to advocate for enduring solutions.
* “How to assemble Parliamentary Assemblies” Series: Building institutional capacity for regional and global parliamentary cooperation,enhancing people’s participation in governance.
Dr. Sharei’s decades of experience within civil society – including involvement with the World Federalist movement and the coalition for the International criminal Court – underscores his commitment to a more just and equitable world order.
The Path Forward: Reclaiming the Promise
The reactivation of the San Francisco Promise is not merely an academic exercise. It represents a concrete opportunity to address the systemic shortcomings of the United Nations and build a more effective framework for global cooperation. Dr. Sharei’s work provides a roadmap for achieving this goal, emphasizing the importance of:
*
