English rugby’s second tier, the RFU Championship, faces an uncertain future as the sport shifts toward a “franchise” model under the new Professional Game Partnership (PGP). With the Gallagher Premiership effectively ringfenced and the traditional promotion-relegation mechanism suspended, the pathway for clubs outside the top flight has been fundamentally altered, leaving stakeholders to question the long-term viability of the Championship.
The transition is part of a broader restructuring agreement between the Rugby Football Union (RFU) and Premiership Rugby, announced in September 2024, which aims to secure the financial stability of elite English rugby. Under the new Professional Game Partnership, the top tier is moving toward a model where participation is based on financial and operational criteria rather than purely sporting merit. This shift marks the end of an era where Championship winners could automatically ascend to the Premiership, provided they met minimum stadium standards.
The Evolution of the Premiership Model
For decades, the promotion-relegation battle defined the English club structure, creating both high-stakes tension and significant financial volatility. However, the collapse of three Premiership clubs—Wasps, Worcester Warriors, and London Irish—during the 2022-2023 season accelerated the demand for a more sustainable, closed-shop approach. According to Premiership Rugby, the new structure is designed to foster closer alignment between the clubs and the national team, prioritizing long-term investment over the risks associated with sudden relegation.
This structural change means that clubs in the Championship are no longer operating with the immediate prospect of reaching the top tier. For many, the Championship served as a proving ground for ambitious teams. Without that carrot, the incentive for private investment in second-tier clubs has cooled significantly. The RFU has acknowledged that the new model requires a “reimagining” of the second tier, though specific details on how the league will be funded or marketed in the absence of a promotion pathway remain in development.
Financial Implications for Second-Tier Clubs
The financial pressure on Championship clubs has been a persistent theme in English rugby. Historically, these clubs have relied on a mix of central RFU funding, local sponsorship, and match-day revenue. With the PGP emphasizing the concentration of resources at the top level, Championship clubs face a challenging economic environment.
The Rugby Players Association (RPA) has previously expressed concerns regarding the welfare and career progression of players in the second tier. If the Championship is reduced to a developmental league or a semi-professional entity, the number of full-time professional contracts available to players will inevitably shrink. This potential contraction raises questions about the depth of the talent pool available to the England national team, which has historically relied on the Championship to provide game time for emerging players.
What Happens Next for the Championship?
The immediate future of the Championship rests on the upcoming RFU strategic review of the professional pathway. While the Premiership has embraced its new, more insular identity, the RFU is under pressure to demonstrate that it has not abandoned the domestic game’s wider base.
According to the RFU’s official communication on the Professional Game Partnership, the governing body is committed to maintaining a high standard of competition across all levels. However, critics argue that without the “dream” of promotion, the Championship risks becoming a closed ecosystem with limited public interest. The next milestone for the clubs will be the release of the RFU’s updated commercial and broadcasting strategy for the 2025/26 season, which is expected to clarify how the Championship will be positioned within the new professional landscape.
As the sport in England moves into this franchise-style era, the focus shifts from the dramatic survival battles of the past to the administrative and commercial stability of the future. Whether this model succeeds in preventing further club insolvencies remains the central question for the sport’s administrators and fans alike.
How do you view these changes to the English rugby structure? Share your thoughts in the comments below.