Jakarta, Indonesia – Indonesian social media personality Nabilah O’Brien is no longer a suspect in a defamation case following a mediated settlement with musician Zendhy Kusuma, authorities confirmed on Sunday. The resolution brings an end to a months-long dispute stemming from an incident at a Jakarta restaurant and subsequent accusations exchanged online.
The agreement, reached during a meeting at the National Police Headquarters (Mabes Polri) in Jakarta on March 8, 2026, involved the mutual withdrawal of police reports filed by both parties. O’Brien publicly stated after the mediation, “I forgive everything, that’s all, I’m no longer a suspect.” The case had garnered significant attention in Indonesia, highlighting the complexities of online disputes and the application of the country’s electronic information and transactions law.
Details of the Settlement and Police Confirmation
According to Brigadier General Trunoyudo Wisnu Andiko, Head of the Public Information Bureau of the Indonesian National Police (Polri), the peaceful resolution was achieved after direct mediation between the involved parties. “Sister Z and her wife, Sister ES, and also representatives from Sister NA and KDH, all four parties were present and reached a peace agreement,” Trunoyudo stated. “Within this agreement, each party has withdrawn their respective reports filed with the investigating authorities.”
The Polri’s commitment to facilitating a just outcome for all involved was central to the mediation process, Trunoyudo emphasized. He added that the move towards peace was also underpinned by a spirit of self-reflection, particularly during the holy month of Ramadan, which emphasizes reconciliation, and forgiveness. “The projection going forward from this mediation is to provide a sense of complete justice for both parties and the wider community,” he said.
The dispute originated from an incident on September 19, 2025, at the Bibi Kelinci restaurant in Kemang, South Jakarta. Zendhy Kusuma and his wife, Evi Santi, reportedly ordered 11 food items and three beverages totaling Rp 530,150 (approximately $33 USD based on current exchange rates). A disagreement ensued, and the couple allegedly left the restaurant without paying, leading to accusations of theft and subsequent legal action.
Dual Investigations and the Path to Mediation
The situation escalated with both parties filing counter-reports. Nabilah O’Brien was initially named a suspect on February 28, 2026, by the Directorate of Cyber Crime at the National Police Criminal Investigation Unit (Bareskrim Polri) on allegations of defamation and spreading false information under the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (UU ITE). Zendhy Kusuma and his wife also faced a separate investigation at the Mampang Prapatan Police Sector following a report filed by O’Brien on February 24, 2026.
To resolve the conflicting investigations, the Criminal Investigation Unit’s Supervision Bureau (Biro Pengawasan Penyidikan Bareskrim Polri) conducted an analysis of both reports. This analysis aimed to identify common ground and facilitate a peaceful resolution. The subsequent mediation process, overseen by Polri officials, ultimately led to the agreement for both parties to withdraw their complaints.
As part of the settlement, both O’Brien and Kusuma agreed to remove any offensive content related to the dispute from their respective social media accounts. This commitment to digital cleanup underscores the growing importance of online reputation management and the potential legal ramifications of online behavior in Indonesia.
Implications of the Settlement and the Role of Ramadan
The amicable resolution of this case is being viewed as a positive step towards promoting restorative justice and peaceful conflict resolution within Indonesia’s legal system. Brigadier General Trunoyudo highlighted the significance of the timing, noting that the agreement was reached during Ramadan, a period traditionally associated with spiritual reflection, forgiveness, and strengthening social bonds. “They realized that this is Ramadan, a time for worship, a blessing, and fostering good relations and introspection,” he explained.
The case also highlights the increasing prevalence of disputes originating online and escalating into legal battles. Indonesia’s UU ITE, while intended to regulate online activity and protect citizens from cybercrime, has been criticized for its broad scope and potential for misuse. The O’Brien-Kusuma case underscores the demand for careful consideration of the law’s application and the importance of mediation in resolving online conflicts.
Zendhy Kusuma has previously claimed to have paid for the meal at Bibi Kelinci on two occasions, totaling Rp 1.1 million (approximately $70 USD). However, the details of the restaurant incident and the payment dispute remain a point of contention, and the settlement does not explicitly address the veracity of these claims.
The resolution of this case is expected to provide a sense of closure for both Nabilah O’Brien and Zendhy Kusuma, allowing them to move forward. The Polri’s role in facilitating the mediation demonstrates a commitment to resolving disputes peacefully and upholding the principles of justice and fairness. The focus now shifts to ensuring that the terms of the agreement are fully implemented, including the removal of offensive content from social media platforms.
As the investigation concludes, the focus will be on the continued enforcement of the UU ITE and the promotion of responsible online behavior. The O’Brien-Kusuma case serves as a reminder of the potential legal consequences of online actions and the importance of exercising caution and respect in digital interactions.
The Indonesian National Police have not indicated any further action will be taken in this matter, and both parties have expressed a desire to move forward. The public will be watching to witness how this case influences future approaches to resolving online disputes and the application of Indonesia’s electronic information laws.
What happens next? The Polri will continue to monitor the situation to ensure compliance with the terms of the peace agreement. Both Nabilah O’Brien and Zendhy Kusuma are expected to refrain from making any further public statements that could reignite the dispute.
What are your thoughts on this resolution? Share your comments below and let us know what you think about the role of social media in public disputes.