Dr. Casey Means’ Surgeon General Nomination Faces Scrutiny Ahead of Senate Hearing
The Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Commitee has scheduled a virtual confirmation hearing for Dr. Casey Means, President Trump’s nominee for Surgeon general, on october 30th. This hearing comes five months after her initial nomination and amidst increasing scrutiny regarding her financial interests and the scientific basis of some of her health advocacy.
Here’s a comprehensive look at the nomination, the background surrounding it, and the concerns being raised:
A Delayed Confirmation Process
The path to confirmation hasn’t been straightforward. The hearing was delayed as dr. Means, currently pregnant and residing in Kilauea, Hawaii, finalized her financial and ethics disclosures. These disclosures have become a focal point of debate.
Dr. Means’ nomination followed the withdrawal of Janette Nesheiwat’s candidacy earlier this year, after questions arose about her qualifications. If the HELP Committee approves her, a full Senate vote will determine her confirmation.
Who is Dr. Casey Means?
Dr. Means, 38, is a physician who has become a prominent voice in the wellness space, especially focusing on the impact of diet and nutrition on chronic illness. Her background includes medical training at Stanford University, though she left her surgical residency program, expressing disillusionment with the financial incentives driving medical care.
She co-founded Levels, a health tech company promoting the use of continuous glucose monitoring to track individual health data. This aligns with the “Make America Healthy Again” movement championed by Health and Human services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who advocates for widespread adoption of wearable health-tracking devices. Notably, Dr. Means is also the sister of Calley Means, an advisor to Kennedy.
Financial Disclosures Raise Questions
Recent financial disclosures have sparked controversy. The New York Times reported that Dr. Means has financially benefited from her advocacy for diet as a primary factor in health.
Here’s a breakdown of key findings:
* Newsletter Income: Approximately $116,000 earned over an 18-month period through sponsorships.
* Book Tour & Sponsorships: $79,000 from Swiss firm Amazentis for newsletter sponsorship and $55,000 for her book tour.
* Book Sales: Revenue exceeding $100,000, but less than $1 million, from her book, “Good Energy: The Surprising Connection Between Metabolism and Limitless Health.”
* supplement & Meal Delivery Payments: Financial ties to companies selling dietary supplements and home meal delivery services.
These financial connections have led some critics to question the objectivity of her health recommendations and whether they are truly rooted in scientific evidence. Concerns have been raised that her advocacy could potentially cause harm if not grounded in rigorous research.
The Core of Her Advocacy: Metabolism and Chronic Illness
Dr. Means argues that diet is often the underlying cause of many chronic illnesses. She champions a focus on metabolic health and believes optimizing nutrition can significantly improve overall well-being.
This viewpoint resonates with Secretary kennedy’s vision for preventative healthcare, but it also places her in a position where her personal beliefs and financial interests intersect.
Concerns About Scientific Basis
While Dr. Means’ focus on preventative health is widely supported, some experts express concern that her claims aren’t always supported by robust scientific evidence.PBS NewsHour highlighted these criticisms, suggesting her advocacy may lack sufficient scientific backing.
As you consider this nomination,it’s critically important to weigh Dr. Means’ passion for wellness against the potential conflicts of interest and the need for evidence-based public health recommendations. The upcoming Senate hearing will undoubtedly delve deeper into these critical issues.
Sources:
* UPI
* ABC News
* The Hill
![Comeback Story: From Vulnerability to Victory | [Keyword related to the story’s subject]](https://i0.wp.com/www.nme.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/lily-allen-west-end-girl-credit-charlie-denis.jpg?resize=150%2C150&ssl=1 "Comeback Story: From Vulnerability to Victory | [Keyword related to the story’s subject]")
