James L. Brooks‘ “Ella McCay“: A Flawed, Yet Refreshing Return to Form
After a 15-year hiatus, James L. Brooks-the celebrated director behind classics like “terms of Endearment” and “As good as It Gets”-returns to the big screen with “Ella McCay.” The film, starring Mackenzie Mackey in the title role, offers a distinctly unmodern cinematic experience. It’s a choice Brooks readily acknowledges, and one that ultimately proves both its strength and weakness.
Brooks, who also juggles his day job as a writer on The Simpsons, felt a creative pull to return to feature filmmaking. As he explained, he simply needed to write again. But does that translate to a compelling film in today’s landscape? Let’s dive in.
A Governor‘s Uphill Battle
“Ella McCay” centers on a newly appointed governor, brimming with idealism and a refusal to compromise her principles. Mackey portrays Ella as genuinely elated to serve, eager to roll up her sleeves and get to work. However, she quickly discovers that navigating the treacherous waters of politics won’t be easy.
Several personal challenges further complicate matters:
* Ryan (Jack Lowden): Ella’s husband is presented as an unpredictable element in her life.
* Her Father (Woody Harrelson): A reformed womanizer seeking forgiveness, adding emotional weight to Ella’s already demanding position.
* A Principled Stance: Ella’s unwavering refusal to engage in political maneuvering,even if it jeopardizes her career,forms the core of her character.
The film is set in 2008, a detail that proves surprisingly crucial. The “scandal” that threatens Ella’s governorship would likely be a minor blip in today’s hyper-sensitive media environment. As the review notes, it might not even register a full “Outrage Cycle™.”
Brooks’ Signature Style: A Breath of Fresh Air?
Critics have labeled Brooks’ script and tone as “stuffy” and “old-fashioned.” He doesn’t deny it. in a world saturated with fast-paced editing and predictable plots, Brooks delivers something different. He prioritizes character progress and dialog with a “bounce” that’s often missing from mainstream cinema.
You’ll find more genuine life in a brooks scene than in many corporate-produced films. While sometimes bordering on excessive, this vibrancy is a welcome change of pace.
Jamie Lee curtis shines as Ella’s Aunt, radiating infectious joie de vivre.Her performance provides a necessary counterpoint to Mackey’s more serious portrayal,preventing the film from becoming overly somber.
Where “Ella McCay” Stumbles
The film isn’t without its flaws. A romantic subplot involving Ella’s younger brother (Spike Feam) feels extraneous and slows the narrative momentum. It’s a storyline that could have been, and arguably should have been, cut.
Similarly, a connection between Ella and a member of her security detail (Kumail Nanjiani) hints at a compelling dynamic, but ultimately fizzles out, punctuated by an awkward cameo from Brooks’ son, Joey Brooks.
the dynamic between Ella and her father, while offering some bitter laughs, could have benefited from further development. A few additional scenes would have allowed their reconciliation to feel more earned.
A Nuanced Political Portrait
One of the film’s strongest elements is the portrayal of a seasoned politician (played by brooks himself). He’s not a villain, but a pragmatic “Beltway creature” struggling to reconcile his ambition with his conscience. Brooks delivers a light, effortless performance, effectively contrasting with Ella’s idealistic worldview.
A Director for a Different Time
At 85, James L. Brooks isn’t chasing trends. He’s making movies for an audience that appreciates thoughtful storytelling,character-driven narratives,and dialogue that isn’t churned out by an AI. “Ella McCay” is unapologetically old-fashioned, and that’s precisely what makes it special.
The Verdict: “Ella McCay” is a flawed but undeniably welcome return for James L. Brooks. it’s a film that reminds you of a time when movies prioritized substance over spectacle.
**HiT or Miss
Related reading