the Mounting Crisis at Medical Properties Trust: A Deep Dive into Rent, Reputation, and a Tragic Outcome
Medical Properties Trust (MPT), a real estate investment trust (REIT) specializing in hospital properties, found itself embroiled in a complex web of financial maneuvering, aggressive PR tactics, and ultimately, a devastating patient death. This examination reveals how a relentless focus on stock price and reputation management, coupled with a business model predicated on high rents, contributed to a crisis that exposed systemic failures within the healthcare system.
For months, MPT executives grappled with negative scrutiny. They questioned whether their extensive network of advisors – their ”army” as they called it – possessed the necessary influence with regulators. A key figure identified within that network was Mick Mulvaney, former Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and acting Chief of Staff to President Trump.
Mulvaney, through his consulting firm Actum, was brought on to “combat” perceived attacks on the company. Actum produced a white paper touting MPT as a vital investor in healthcare,a narrative that sharply contrasted with the growing concerns surrounding its practices. (Actum declined to comment when contacted by Mother Jones.)
While reputation management is standard practice for public companies, the scale of MPT’s efforts was, according to Jo-Ellen Pozner, a professor of business ethics at Santa Clara University, “unequivocally not normal.” Pozner observes that the willingness to expend significant resources investigating journalists and analysts suggests a pervasive culture of suspicion and a belief that everyone else is engaged in similar surveillance.
this intense focus on image control masked a far more troubling reality: the hospitals leasing properties from MPT were facing severe financial strain. Years of escalating rent payments had left these facilities struggling to meet basic operational needs.
A System Under Strain: The Consequences of High Rents
The consequences were dire. Hospitals under Steward Healthcare, a major MPT tenant, were unable to pay on-call doctors, nursing agencies, repair services, and even essential suppliers - including those providing critical items like blood and hospital beds. This financial pressure ultimately led to hospital closures, further depressing MPT’s stock price.
Despite these warning signs, MPT CEO Ed Aldag continued to project confidence, assuring shareholders in October 2023 that the company’s “proven business model” remained sound. Though, the situation at St. Elizabeth’s Hospital in Massachusetts was rapidly deteriorating.
The hospital owed over $500,000 to a supplier of embolism coils - devices used to stop internal bleeding. The supplier, forced to repossess the coils due to non-payment, unknowingly set in motion a tragic chain of events.
A Mother’s Death and a system Exposed
On November 17, 2023, Sungida Rashid delivered her baby girl at St. Elizabeth’s. Hours later, she began to hemorrhage. Doctors discovered they lacked the necessary embolism coil to treat her, and tragically, she died.
Rashid’s death sparked outrage, triggering investigations, hearings, and subpoenas aimed at uncovering the financial connections between MPT and Steward. it took years, and the loss of a mother’s life, for the full extent of the crisis to come to light.
The story of MPT and Steward serves as a stark warning about the potential consequences of prioritizing financial engineering over patient care. It highlights the critical need for clarity and accountability within the healthcare real estate sector, and the devastating impact that unchecked financial pressures can have on the most vulnerable among us.
Additional reporting by Khadija Sharife.
Worth a look