james May’s Royal oak vs. Jeremy Clarkson’s Diddly Squat: A Pub Comparison
Former Top Gear hosts James May and Jeremy Clarkson have both ventured into the world of pub ownership. Though, their approaches – and the resulting establishments – are strikingly different. A recent TikTok review by content creator philc84 offers a detailed comparison, revealing what you can expect from a visit to each.
This article dives deep into the experiences at both pubs, providing a comprehensive overview to help you decide which one might be worth a visit. We’ll explore the atmosphere, pricing, accommodation, and the underlying philosophies driving each venture.
James May’s Royal Oak: A Community-Focused Revival
James May’s Royal Oak,nestled in the quaint Wiltshire village of Swallowcliffe (population 174),isn’t just a business venture; it’s a community lifeline. May, alongside entrepreneur Simon Andrews, purchased a half-share in the pub in 2020 with the explicit goal of preserving it as a local gathering place.
This wasn’t about flipping property or creating a lavish destination. Instead, it was a genuine effort to save a vital part of village life. This commitment resonates with patrons, creating a welcoming and authentic atmosphere.
Here’s what you can expect at The Royal Oak:
Location & Charm: The pub is somewhat secluded, adding to its peaceful appeal.
Accommodation: Rooms are available, with mid-level options costing around £175 per night (including breakfast). While agreeable, expect a no-frills experience. The reviewer noted a slightly temperamental, “diesel-powered” sounding shower.
Pricing: A pint will set you back approximately £6.50 – reasonable for the area.
Atmosphere: Less bustling than clarkson’s pub, offering a more relaxed and intimate experience.
Food & Value: The reviewer found the meal to be fairly priced and a “more than fair exchange.”
Added Bonus: May has even launched his own brand of gin, available at the pub.
May himself embodies a pragmatic approach, seemingly prioritizing functionality over luxury. As philc84 put it, “Is there a lock on the door, and is there a bed? And if the answer to both of those questions is yes, than what more do you want?”
Jeremy Clarkson’s Diddly Squat Farm Shop & pub: A Destination Experience
In contrast, Jeremy Clarkson’s venture, the Farmer’s Dog in the Cotswolds, feels less like a traditional pub and more like a tourist attraction. While undeniably popular, it’s geared towards visitors seeking a photo prospect and a souvenir.
The focus is heavily on merchandise and creating an “Instagrammable” experience. This isn’t necessarily a negative, but it’s a significant departure from the community-focused ethos of May’s pub.
Key differences between the two establishments:
Purpose: royal Oak prioritizes being a local pub; Diddly Squat leans into being a destination.
Atmosphere: Royal Oak is relaxed and intimate; Diddly Squat is often crowded and lively.
Focus: Royal Oak centers on traditional pub fare and community; Diddly Squat emphasizes retail and spectacle.
Which Pub Should You Visit?
The choice between James May’s Royal oak and Jeremy Clarkson’s Diddly Squat depends on your priorities.
Choose The Royal Oak if: You’re seeking an authentic pub experience, a peaceful escape, and a chance to support a community-focused establishment. It’s ideal for a stopover while exploring the West Country or visiting nearby Stonehenge.
Choose Diddly Squat if: You’re looking for a lively atmosphere, a unique shopping experience, and don’t mind crowds.
Ultimately, both pubs offer something different. Philc84’s conclusion is insightful: “Don’t come here [Royal Oak] for a week on holiday or a honeymoon, but do stop in for a night.” James May has successfully secured a valuable community asset, and the locals have responded by creating a truly excellent pub.
Sources:
Rightmove:[https://www.rightmove.co.uk/house-prices/Swallowcliffe/