The world of professional wrestling is constantly evolving and former WWE color commentator and current ESPN personality Pat McAfee seems to be acknowledging a shift that may leave him on the sidelines. McAfee recently indicated that he feels the current WWE landscape has moved on without him, though he remains a fan of the product. This comes after a period of absence from the company, initially attributed to burnout and a demanding schedule, and despite previous indications from WWE leadership that a return was possible.
Speaking during a question-and-answer session on his Instagram Stories, McAfee addressed the possibility of rejoining WWE. While not ruling it out entirely – stating, “I don’t think you ever say never, especially with WWE” – he expressed a sense that the opportunity may have passed. “But right now it does not feel like it is something is supposed to happen. Feels like that business has kind of passed me by a little bit,” McAfee said, according to reports. He also conveyed deep respect for his time with the company, particularly his collaboration with veteran commentator Michael Cole, calling Cole “the GOAT.” Despite his personal feelings, McAfee believes WWE is currently thriving without his involvement, stating, “I feel like the biz is in a good spot without me. I’ll continue to watch.”
McAfee’s WWE Journey: From NXT to WrestlePalooza
Pat McAfee’s foray into professional wrestling began with NXT, WWE’s developmental brand, in 2020. He quickly became a popular figure, known for his energetic commentary and willingness to engage with the performers. His transition to the main roster saw him providing color commentary alongside Michael Cole on Monday Night Raw, a role he embraced and excelled in. He wasn’t limited to the commentary booth, however, as McAfee also stepped into the ring, competing against established WWE stars like Gunther, Austin Theory, and The Miz. These matches, while showcasing his athleticism and bravery, also highlighted his commitment to fully immersing himself in the world of professional wrestling.
However, the demanding schedule of balancing his WWE commitments with his daily ESPN display, The Pat McAfee Show, and his role as an analyst for ESPN’s College GameDay, ultimately took its toll. In June 2025, McAfee stepped away from his regular WWE duties, citing mental exhaustion and burnout. He briefly returned for WrestlePalooza, the inaugural premium live event held in Indianapolis on September 20, 2025, but has not resumed his commentary position since. WrestlePalooza, a significant event for the city and WWE, demonstrated the company’s commitment to expanding its reach and engaging with new audiences.
Balancing Broadcasting Commitments and a Potential Return
Despite his absence from WWE television, McAfee has remained a prominent figure in the broadcasting world. The Pat McAfee Show continues to attract high-profile guests, including Olympic skier Mikaela Shiffrin and NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers. His analytical skills are also regularly featured on ESPN’s College GameDay, providing insightful commentary during the college football season. This continued success in other broadcasting ventures suggests that McAfee has successfully navigated a path that allows him to maintain a high profile without the intense demands of a full-time WWE schedule.
The situation was further complicated by comments made by WWE President Nick Khan in December 2025. Khan indicated that the company intended to bring McAfee back following the conclusion of the college football season. However, McAfee’s recent statements suggest that those plans may not materialize. This discrepancy highlights the dynamic nature of the relationship between McAfee and WWE, and the potential for shifting priorities on both sides. The WWE’s business has continued to thrive, with record revenue reported in early 2026, according to the company’s quarterly earnings report. WWE’s financial reports demonstrate the company’s continued growth and success.
The Evolving Landscape of WWE Commentary
The WWE commentary team has undergone significant changes in recent years. Michael Cole remains a central figure, but the departure of other commentators and the addition of new voices have reshaped the dynamic. The current commentary teams are focused on providing a blend of analysis, storytelling, and fan engagement. The company has also invested heavily in developing new talent, both in front of and behind the camera, to ensure the long-term sustainability of its product. This focus on internal development may contribute to McAfee’s feeling that WWE is “in a good spot” without him, as the company appears to have established a strong foundation for future success.
The wrestling industry itself has also evolved. The rise of independent promotions and the increasing popularity of streaming services have created a more competitive landscape. WWE has responded by expanding its streaming offerings, including the WWE Network, and by forging partnerships with other media companies. This strategic approach has allowed WWE to maintain its position as the industry leader, even in the face of growing competition. The company’s recent deal with NBCUniversal to extend the broadcast of SmackDown through 2027 demonstrates its commitment to maintaining a strong presence on traditional television. Details of the NBCUniversal deal were announced in February 2026.
McAfee’s comments, while seemingly signaling a departure from WWE, don’t entirely close the door on a future return. His statement that “you never say never” leaves room for potential opportunities down the line. However, for now, it appears he is content to focus on his other broadcasting commitments and enjoy WWE as a fan. The wrestling world will be watching to see what the future holds for this versatile and popular personality.
Pat McAfee says “never say never” about a WWE return but feels like the business has passed him by and WWE is in a good spot without him.
🎥: Pat McAfee on IG pic.twitter.com/zWD4IqkQpP
— Wrestling News (@WrestlingNewsCo) March 9, 2026
The next major event for WWE is WrestleMania XL, scheduled for April 5th and 6th, 2026, at Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Ticket sales and viewership numbers for WrestleMania XL will provide further insight into the company’s current trajectory and its ability to maintain its momentum. Fans can find more information about WrestleMania XL and ticket availability on the official WWE website. Official WrestleMania website.
What are your thoughts on Pat McAfee’s potential departure from WWE? Share your opinions in the comments below, and be sure to share this article with fellow wrestling fans!