breaking the Stalemate: A Strategy to Compel Russia to Negotiate in Ukraine
The war in Ukraine has reached a critical juncture. While Russia continues to suffer setbacks, President Putin shows no genuine inclination toward meaningful negotiation. He appears to believe time is on his side, and that Western resolve will eventually falter.To break this dangerous stalemate and compel Russia to accept realistic peace terms,a shift in strategy is urgently needed – one that combines increased pressure with a clear signal of unwavering support for Ukraine.
Understanding Putin’s Calculus
Putin’s current approach isn’t driven by strategic ambition, but by a desire to avoid acknowledging failure. He’s unlikely to make the necesary compromises for a just peace as long as he believes he can incrementally achieve his objectives, or simply bleed Ukraine and the West dry. Thus, the core task isn’t to appease him, but to fundamentally alter his calculations. He must realize that continued aggression will only bring further pain and isolation.
Strengthening ukraine’s Position
The recent €90 billion aid package from the European Union is a vital step, demonstrating a long-term commitment to Kyiv’s stability. The United States must match this commitment with its own robust and sustained support. Here’s how:
* Surge Military Assistance: focus on providing Ukraine with the tools it needs to not only defend its territory, but also to credibly threaten Russian forces. This includes bolstering air defense systems and providing long-range strike capabilities.
* Financing options: Much of this assistance can be financed through European contributions,easing the burden on U.S. taxpayers.
* Winter Endurance: Equipping Ukraine to endure the coming winter is paramount.Continued military aid will help Ukraine maintain its defensive posture and inflict costs on Russia during a traditionally difficult period for offensives.
Turning the Screws: Economic pressure
Military aid alone isn’t enough. We must intensify economic pressure on the Kremlin, targeting its revenue streams and limiting its ability to fund the war.
* Enforce Existing Sanctions: the Treasury department needs to rigorously enforce existing sanctions targeting russia’s top oil companies.
* Expand Sanctions Scope: Target unsanctioned Russian oil suppliers, and also the entities, vessels, and infrastructure facilitating oil exports.
* End the Price Cap: Replace the current biden-era price cap on Russian oil with a full ban on providing shipping or financial services for those exports. This will significantly reduce Russia’s oil revenue.
Improving ukraine’s Battlefield Tactics
While Western support is crucial, Ukraine must also optimize its own military strategy.
* Prioritize Manpower: Ukraine needs to avoid costly engagements focused on reclaiming insignificant territory or defending semi-encircled towns. These tactics deplete precious manpower and resources.
* Strategic Focus: Instead of attempting to mirror Russian offensives, Ukraine should concentrate on weakening Russia’s logistical lines and targeting high-value assets.
* address concerns: Kyiv’s Western partners should reassure Ukraine that battlefield setbacks won’t automatically translate into reduced support or pressure for territorial concessions. Transparency and open communication are key.
A Path forward
The Ukrainians are unlikely to voluntarily cede territory. Our goal shouldn’t be to dictate terms to Ukraine, but to create conditions that force Putin to accept a realistic outcome. Rather than attempting to do Putin’s bidding, Washington should focus on convincing Moscow that continued war is a losing proposition.
This requires a unified,resolute approach - one that combines unwavering support for Ukraine with intensified pressure on Russia. Only then can we break the current stalemate and pave the way for a just and lasting peace.
Disclaimer: The Cipher Brief is committed to publishing a range of perspectives on national security issues submitted by deeply experienced national security professionals. Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of The Cipher Brief. Have a viewpoint to share based on your experience in the national security field? Send it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration. Read more expert-driven national security insights, perspective and analysis in The Cipher Brief, because national security is everyone’s business.
