Turkey‘s Shifting Regional Role: From Neo-Ottoman Ambitions to Pragmatic Security Provider
Turkey is undergoing a notable foreign policy recalibration,driven by evolving regional dynamics and a changing global order. for years,Ankara pursued an aspiring vision of regional leadership. Now, it finds itself navigating a far more complex landscape, increasingly defined by pragmatic security concerns and a diminished faith in universally beneficial partnerships. This analysis explores Turkey’s evolving role,its potential as a security partner,and the implications for the future of regional stability.
The Erosion of the Liberal international Order
The post-Cold War era’s emphasis on win-win cooperation is fading.A new era of “Risk geopolitics” is emerging, characterized by competition to redefine rules and redraw borders. This shift fundamentally alters Turkey’s strategic calculus. Previously, Ankara could project influence thru economic and diplomatic means, aligning with a broadly accepted liberal international order. Now, it must contend with a world where power dynamics are more overtly competitive and security concerns take precedence.
Turkey’s Pragmatic Pivot: A New security Framework
Several factors are contributing to this shift.
* the Ukraine War and Russia: A key argument gaining traction is that European security increasingly relies on Turkey’s military capabilities to contain Russia, particularly given potential uncertainties surrounding continued U.S. support.
* Israel‘s Actions and Regional Realignment: Israel’s increasingly assertive behavior has paradoxically improved Turkey’s standing with its arab neighbors.Egypt and Gulf states are showing greater willingness to coordinate with Ankara, viewing it as a potential counterweight to Israeli influence.
* A Reassessment of “Neo-ottomanism”: The ambitious “neo-ottoman” vision championed by former Foreign Minister ahmet Davutoglu,once lauded and later criticized,is now viewed through a different lens. While initially dismissed as grandiose, it shared underlying assumptions with the post-Cold War liberal order – a belief in mutually beneficial power dynamics.
Davutoglu’s vision: A Regional EU?
Davutoglu envisioned Turkey as a regional powerbroker, akin to Germany within the European Union. His concept of a Turkish sphere of influence resembled a Balkan and Middle Eastern equivalent of the EU, fostering economic and diplomatic ties. This model, like the U.S.-led liberal international order, promised shared benefits for all involved. Though, as Selim Koru points out, this relentlessly positive framing always felt somewhat implausible.
From Win-Win to Lesser Evil
The optimistic ”win-win” rhetoric is largely gone. Today, countries are increasingly seeking partners not based on shared ideals, but on who represents the “lesser evil” in the face of immediate threats. You’ll notice a shift in Turkey’s approach, moving away from idealistic visions toward a more pragmatic focus on security and national interests. This is a direct response to the changing geopolitical landscape.
Turkey’s Current Position: A Crowded Field
After a period of embracing irredentism,Turkey now operates in a crowded field of competing powers. The world is witnessing a resurgence of great power competition and a breakdown of established norms. This presents both challenges and opportunities for Ankara.
* Increased Competition: Turkey must navigate a complex web of relationships with Russia, the United States, European nations, and regional rivals.
* Heightened Security Concerns: The rise of instability and conflict in the Middle East and beyond necessitates a stronger focus on security cooperation.
* Potential for Leadership: Turkey’s strategic location,military capabilities,and diplomatic experience position it as a potential leader in addressing regional challenges.
What This Means for You and Regional Stability
The evolving role of Turkey has significant implications for regional stability and your understanding of the geopolitical landscape.
* A More Pragmatic Turkey: Expect Ankara to prioritize its national interests and engage in more transactional relationships.
* Increased Security Cooperation: Turkey is likely to seek closer security ties with countries that share its concerns,even if those relationships are not based on ideological alignment.
* A Potential Security Provider: Turkey could play a crucial role in containing Russia, countering terrorism, and managing regional conflicts.
ultimately, the future remains uncertain. The past’s optimistic assumptions may not hold true in this new era
Related reading